Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Got questions? We got answers....
Post Reply
BeanStalk
Supporting Member II
Supporting Member II
Posts: 7
Joined: 06:45 pm May 30 2012
Country:

Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by BeanStalk »

Tonight we re-assembled the cases on our '04 KDX220. RB rebuilt the crank with a new Hot Rods rod & bearings. Installed new main bearings and seals. Taking no chances after an OEM piston failure (yes, all the warnings are true, and some of us don't find this forum until AFTER she blows!).

First - froze the bearings in Acetone and dry ice, warmed the case halves in the oven, and they dropped right in place. Just as advertised - no drama. Bearins spin nice and free.
Second - froze the crank overnight in the family fridge. Tested fit on unheated, installed bearings - slid right in the right side.
Third - stuck the crank back into the freezer while we gooped up the halves (Yamabond 4).
Fourth - dropped the crank easily into the right side, then lowered the left side over it. Got to about 3/8" case separation, then tapped it home with a soft wood block and hammer (just on the frame mounting bolt holes).
Fifth - torqued all bolts to spec in alternating pattern.

Now, trans shafts spin freely. But crankshaft takes a lot more effort to turn than I expected. I can turn it, but it takes some effort. Once at bottom of stroke, I need to help with a finger twist on the crank end to bring it back to TDC, but once there, can rock it back and forth just pushing/pulling on the rod small end.

Question (already): is this normal - just needs to be broken in? Or did I screw something up? Crank appears to be tighter against the right case than the left, so I don't think I forced anything together against its will.

I don't want to over worry it, but hate to keep going if I have a problem.

Thanks!
2004 KDX220 (Son's)
2008 KLX140 (Daughter's)
2007 KLX300
User avatar
rbates9
Supporting Member II
Supporting Member II
Posts: 3164
Joined: 06:07 pm Apr 27 2010
Country:
Location: UPSTATE New York

Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by rbates9 »

I just did crank seals and used the Tusk crank puller to put the left side back on. That tool works great! I would guess that you have too much side load on the left crank bearing. I also did the freezer and heat thing to put the crank in but you just don't have enough time to get the left cover on while the crank is cold.

You could try swatting the crank back and forth but mine goes back together VERY tight so it may take more than that.
User avatar
SS109
KDXRider.net
KDXRider.net
Posts: 5770
Joined: 05:11 am Aug 23 2009
Country: USA
Location: Tucson, AZ, USA
Contact:

Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by SS109 »

I could be wrong but it sounds like to me you are just experiencing what all engines do when they get to BDC. It will always be harder to get it coming back up as the crank isn't really spinning. Try pushing down on the rod hard enough that the inertia of the crank while rotate itself past BDC and see if the resistance is the same then. Also, did you lube the bearing (crank and rod) at all? Dry bearings will have more resistance than lubed ones, obviously. Just something to check. If the resistance changes during the rotation then something is wrong. Normally that means the crank isn't indexed (trued) correctly.
Youtube Channel: WildAzzRacing
AZ State Parks & Trails OHV Ambassador - Trail Riders of Southern AZ
Current KDX: '98 KDX220
Old KDX: '90 KDX200 -White/Blue
'11 GasGas EC250R
BeanStalk
Supporting Member II
Supporting Member II
Posts: 7
Joined: 06:45 pm May 30 2012
Country:

Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by BeanStalk »

Thanks for the responses. The resistance is constant through all 360 degrees, and I don't feel any interference, for example no rattle or clicks. RB Designs assembled the crank, so I'm confident it is true. I did not lubricate the bearings before assembly - was debating heating the cases, and didn't want more oil smoke in the kitchen if we went the route!

BTW - I read a previous thread where the hot case, cold crank method was discussed. I couldn't figure out how to get the gasket goop on the cases doing this, unless applying it before heating (baking it, and risking a bad seal). Otherwise, the cases would cool while I'm smearing it on, defeating the purpose? Decided against.

I did a test assembly of the cases without the crank, to make sure I had everything in place and that the sides would pull in tightly. I needed to tap it the last ~1/4" even without the crank. I was sure it was just resistance from the two dowels that prevented me from pushing the halves together with my hands. I don't think I encountered a lot more resistance than that with the crank in place - possibly a little more. The crank had been out of the freezer only seconds at that point - literally maybe 10 seconds.

My conclusions at this point: 1. the bearings are new/dry, and therefore stiff. All will be fine after break in; and 2. the crankshaft in the freezer overnight method worked pretty slick.

If everything blows up on the first ride, well, then I'll adjust my self confidence settings :oops:
2004 KDX220 (Son's)
2008 KLX140 (Daughter's)
2007 KLX300
User avatar
kawagumby
Gold Member
Gold Member
Posts: 927
Joined: 10:09 am Nov 30 2006
Country:
Location: California

Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by kawagumby »

I've had cranks feel a little tight after assembly, and usually I can free them up by just whacking both ends with a hammer (wood in between) - sometimes thats all it takes to get the ass'y to seat properly and spin easily.
1994 KDX200, Beta 200rr, yz125, yz250, kx100 modded for adult, gasgas contact 250.
User avatar
Julien D
KDXRider.net
KDXRider.net
Posts: 5858
Joined: 07:53 pm Nov 07 2008
Country: USA
Contact:

Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by Julien D »

kawagumby wrote:I've had cranks feel a little tight after assembly, and usually I can free them up by just whacking both ends with a hammer (wood in between) - sometimes thats all it takes to get the ass'y to seat properly and spin easily.

Yep. Also look with the jug removed and make sure the clearance is the same on either side of the crank lobes.
Image
User avatar
Slick_Nick
Supporting Member
Posts: 1675
Joined: 10:06 pm Oct 22 2009
Country: Canada
Location: Calgary, Alberta
Contact:

Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by Slick_Nick »

Don't try the heat freeze method for the final assembly. You NEED a crank puller for that final step. THE CASE BOLTS WILL NOT CUT IT!
'00 KDX 220R
User avatar
Julien D
KDXRider.net
KDXRider.net
Posts: 5858
Joined: 07:53 pm Nov 07 2008
Country: USA
Contact:

Re: Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by Julien D »

Slick_Nick wrote:Don't try the heat freeze method for the final assembly. You NEED a crank puller for that final step. THE CASE BOLTS WILL NOT CUT IT!
I've done it without a crank puller about half a dozen times in the past couple years. No problems.
Image
User avatar
rbates9
Supporting Member II
Supporting Member II
Posts: 3164
Joined: 06:07 pm Apr 27 2010
Country:
Location: UPSTATE New York

Re: Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by rbates9 »

Julien D wrote:
Slick_Nick wrote:Don't try the heat freeze method for the final assembly. You NEED a crank puller for that final step. THE CASE BOLTS WILL NOT CUT IT!
I've done it without a crank puller about half a dozen times in the past couple years. No problems.
The last time I did it I used the case bolts and it worked. This time I froze the crank to drop it into the right case and then I used a crank puller for the left side. Once you try a crank puller you won't want to do it any other way. I was trying to get everything lined up and by the time I did the cases were back together. I kinda thought I missed something it worked that good.
User avatar
Julien D
KDXRider.net
KDXRider.net
Posts: 5858
Joined: 07:53 pm Nov 07 2008
Country: USA
Contact:

Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by Julien D »

Yeah, It's a nice to have. Not a necessity though.
Image
BeanStalk
Supporting Member II
Supporting Member II
Posts: 7
Joined: 06:45 pm May 30 2012
Country:

Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by BeanStalk »

Update: crank lobes were not centered in the case opening. Gave the right (primary) end a few good whacks with a hammer and soft (pine) wood block between. This centered the lobes, and freed the crank up nicely to where it would easily spin round and round by just making like a piston on the rod end.

Lessons learned? I can see why the crank puller might be handy - If I had one, I'd still freeze the crank, then I'd use the puller. That said - the frozen crank slipped so easily through the bearings, even the second one - I'd do it again without the puller. But next time I'll lift slightly after dropping it in the right side bearing, before sliding the left side on and tapping it down. But, I'm REALLY hoping there is no next time! :prayer:

Note - I did NOT pull the cases together with the case bolts. I did tap on the frame mount holes to push down onto the two dowels. But since I needed to do the same during my dry run without the crankshaft, I'm pretty sure the bearing was not holding the cases apart.

I really, really appreciate all the quick responses and help! :bravo:
2004 KDX220 (Son's)
2008 KLX140 (Daughter's)
2007 KLX300
User avatar
SS109
KDXRider.net
KDXRider.net
Posts: 5770
Joined: 05:11 am Aug 23 2009
Country: USA
Location: Tucson, AZ, USA
Contact:

Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by SS109 »

Awesome! I'm glad you got it sorted out.
Youtube Channel: WildAzzRacing
AZ State Parks & Trails OHV Ambassador - Trail Riders of Southern AZ
Current KDX: '98 KDX220
Old KDX: '90 KDX200 -White/Blue
'11 GasGas EC250R
User avatar
Mr. Wibbens
KDXRider.net
KDXRider.net
Posts: 4884
Joined: 02:57 am Nov 07 2004
Country:
Location: Playing in the Poison Oak
Contact:

Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by Mr. Wibbens »

Slick_Nick wrote:Don't try the heat freeze method for the final assembly. You NEED a crank puller for that final step. THE CASE BOLTS WILL NOT CUT IT!
bullshit
Warning! This member tends to use sarcasm as a regular form of communication. If a post seems offensive, before you panic and fly off the handle, re-read the post and imagine it being said with a sideways grin.
((Bike Profile))
((Pics))
FIVE OUT OF FOUR PEOPLE DONUT UNDERSTAND FRACTIONS
dfeckel
Platinum Member
Platinum Member
Posts: 644
Joined: 07:46 am Nov 09 2009
Country:

Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by dfeckel »

Although a crank puller likely makes the final case assembly easier, the case bolts will totally pull things back together. I've done it three times. That said, I may well invest in a crank puller next time, as getting the case halves close enough for the bolts to start working was a little iffy.
David Eckel
User avatar
Mr. Wibbens
KDXRider.net
KDXRider.net
Posts: 4884
Joined: 02:57 am Nov 07 2004
Country:
Location: Playing in the Poison Oak
Contact:

Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by Mr. Wibbens »

Just use a little longer bolts to get it started, that way there's no risk of pulling the threads
Warning! This member tends to use sarcasm as a regular form of communication. If a post seems offensive, before you panic and fly off the handle, re-read the post and imagine it being said with a sideways grin.
((Bike Profile))
((Pics))
FIVE OUT OF FOUR PEOPLE DONUT UNDERSTAND FRACTIONS
User avatar
rbates9
Supporting Member II
Supporting Member II
Posts: 3164
Joined: 06:07 pm Apr 27 2010
Country:
Location: UPSTATE New York

Crank reinstalled - not turning freely

Post by rbates9 »

The benefit of the crank puller is that it pulls the crank into the bearing, not push the bearing onto the crank. I have done it both ways and I found the crank puller to be MUCH quicker and when the cases were together the crank spun just like it should. No swatting or reallinging to be done.

It can be done with the case bolts but if you plan on doing more than one case splitting lob than the $50 bucks for the crank puller is a good investment. A few of the guys I ride with and my self have been buying different tools to get the big jobs done and we swap tools as needed. Makes having the right tool a little bit cheaper.
Post Reply